The 10 Best Arrows for Deer Hunting

A decent, high-quality bow is just a part of the best deer bowhunting rig. Arrows, for the most part, deserve as much attention. Overall, you want durable, accurate arrows with just the right stiffness for the job.

Thanks to high-tech carbon construction, arrows for deer hunting are now one step ahead. But it takes more than that to find the best arrows for deer hunting. After all, not many manufacturers are as dedicated to providing the best value for money.

So, give me a few minutes of your time as I round up the best deer-hunting arrows. I’ll try to be more versatile by providing the best options for both target practice and hunting.

10 Best Arrows for Deer Hunting

1. Tiger Archery 30-Inch Carbon Arrows

Tiger Archery is one of the top names in the industry. Among its arsenal are these Tiger Archery 30-inch carbon arrows.

Mostly, these carbon arrows combine precision and extended durability. And with a light draw, they make an excellent choice for long-term target practice.

Long-term durability

Tiger Archery arrows adopt durable components. They have a 0.3-inch double-walled high-tech carbon shaft. Hence, you get the utmost durability in a lightweight package. Also, the multi-layered design reduces the risk of splintering.

The nickel stainless steel field points offer unmatched tolerance. For instance, they combat moisture better for outdoor shooting. Again, they have bullet tips ideal for beginners and target practice. And with O-rings, they never come loose, making them perfect for a stronger target.

Excellent for target shooting

At 13 GPI, these arrows are a bit on the heavy side. After all, there are lighter carbon arrows that hit the scales at 5.5 GPI. So, I would have considered them for deep penetration. However, the 500 spine isn’t as stiff. As such, they’re suitable for low-poundage youth compound bows.

At 40-60 pounds maximum draw weight, you don’t get as much kinetic energy and speed for deep penetration. Hence, I consider it a perfect choice for target shooting.

All-weather rubber fletching

Tiger Archery arrows use standard rubber-based plastic vanes. They’re soft, flexible, and quiet. Also, they’re relatively durable and impervious to water. Hence, they make an excellent all-weather choice.

Easy replacement

The arrowheads and the nocks are replaceable. You can unscrew the field points and replace them with a broadhead. Also, the nocks are not glued. Hence, you can adjust them for your bow.

More in one package

The package includes a set of 12 arrows. Alongside that is a bonus of six nocks.

2. Barnett 16075 Outdoors Carbon Crossbow Arrows

Barnett 16075 carbon crossbow arrows offer incredible value. Most consider them the best crossbow bolts for the money.

These ready-to-shoot carbon arrows combine exceptional accuracy and penetration power. Hence, they’re as good for the bulls-eye as they’re for hunting games.

Excellent penetration edge

Like Tiger Archery, Barnett 16075 arrows come in durable, double-walled carbon shafts. But at 13.78 GPI, these arrows are a bit heavier. Again, the short length makes them stiffer.

With such specs, they can accommodate high-poundage Barnett crossbows. Matched with 100-grain field points, they offer optimal accuracy and penetration power. Hence, they can take down small to medium-sized games with ease.

Guaranteed durability

As one would expect, these carbon arrows offer premium quality, particularly with the improved wall thickness. Hence, they’re guaranteed to last, shot after shot. And to remove any doubts, these carbon arrows come with a 5-year warranty.

Slip-resistant half-moon nocks

The half-moon nocks reward you with a slight curvature. They tend to curve around the string, pinching it slightly. Hence, the arrow is unlikely to slip off or be thrown off the aim.

Easy to track orange fletching

These carbon arrows boast durable fletching for all-weather use. But what I love most is the orange color. The bright color makes it easier to track the arrow.

Wide-range compatibility

As mentioned earlier, these arrows fit high-pound Barnett crossbows. You can use them with Penetrator, Ghost 350, Jackal, and Wildcat C-5 crossbows.

Value Package

The package includes five 20-inch arrows. Alongside that, it comes with moon nocks.

3. Carbon Express PileDriver Carbon Crossbolt

Carbon Express is a go-to choice for elite bowhunters and target archers. It has an impressive lineup of durable, high-strength, and exceptionally accurate cross bolts.

But the title for the heaviest contender goes to the PileDriver cross bolt. It packs exceptional knock-down power for the largest of prey.

Advanced construction

Well, the PileDriver cross bolt isn’t entirely carbon. Instead, it comes in carbon composite material. Unlike standard carbon fiber, it’s stiffer, more durable, and consistent.

A powerhouse bolt for the serious hunter

Carbon Express PileDriver cross bolt is among the most massive offerings. It’s available in two sizes: 442-grain 20-inch and 479-grain 22-inch.

Aside from the heavy grain weight, the shaft comes stiffer. It can fit up to 150-grain broadheads. Hence, it delivers bone-crushing penetration that punches through heavy vertebrae or shoulder blades.

Real Straightness precision

PileDriver Arrow offers exceptional 360-degree spine consistency. And with a maximum straightness of 0.004 inches, it promises a flatter trajectory, shot after shot. Hence, it stays accurate on the target each time, instilling more confidence.

Different types of nocks

The package includes six cross bolts fitted with moon nocks. But inside the box, you also get C nocks and universal flat nocks.

4. Carbon Express Maxima RED Carbon Arrow

Maxima RED carbon arrow offers ground-breaking innovation that redefines broadhead accuracy. For that, it guarantees ultimate hunting performance and precision.

It shoots tighter for unmatched consistency. And as far as it goes, Maxima RED is the best mid-weight hunting arrow ever.

High-tech carbon construction

Maxima RED uses high-tech carbon construction. It has a super-strong diamond weave on the outer layer. Hence, you get one of the toughest carbon arrows. At the same time, the diamond weave construction makes it one of the quietest.

Dynamic spine control

Carbon Express Maxima RED tends to be stiffer at the front end. This allows the shaft to re-position the arrow to the RED ZONE. The result is reduced oscillation, hence more consistent shots. Moreover, it takes only two spine sizes to meet draw weights of 40-92 pounds.

Built for both speed and penetration power

At 9.07 GPI, Maxima RED is a middle-ground compromise. It wields more power to punch through an elk. Likewise, it’s fast enough to nail the zippiest deer.

Laser-checked straightness

Maxima RED provides a truer flight. At 0.0001-inch straightness, it offers ultimate consistency.

Advanced precision nock

This arrow uses an advanced launchpad precision nock that fits the string tightly. Yet it offers ample space for a natural draw and release. For this reason, it provides controlled bow release and better shaft alignment.

Moreover, the nock has an aircraft-grade aluminum collar. It provides superior durability, protecting the arrow end from impact damage.

Available in two spine sizes

Maxima RED 30-inch arrow is available in two spine sizes: 250 and 350.

Premium package

Well, Maxima RED isn’t a ready-to-shoot package. It doesn’t come with arrowheads. Nevertheless, it includes 12 premium arrows, high-quality precision nocks, and durable aluminum collars.

5. Pointdo 30-Inch Carbon Arrow

This is among the flashiest of arrows. It doesn’t deliver bone-crushing penetration. Neither does it promise the most accurate shot.

But from a price-point view, it’s a decent arrow with durable carbon construction. Also, it makes an excellent choice for target practice.

Beautiful, fluorescent arrow

Fluorescent shaft and fletching make this arrow a beauty to behold. But there’s more to the flashy design. It makes the arrow easier to track, even in low-light conditions.

This fluorescent arrow is available in three colors: Green, Red, and Yellow.

Good quality

This arrow has a carbon fiber shaft. Hence, it’s of sufficient strength and durability for hard-hitting targets.

Excellent for target practice

The shaft is rated at 13 GPI. Hence, it’s on the heavy side. But with a 500-spine, it’s not as stiff.

So, I’d recommend this arrow for light-draw compound and recurve bows. Say 25-60 pounds. Thanks to 100-grain field points, you can take it out for a hunt, but only for small animals.

Replaceable nocks and tips

This arrow has 100-grain screw tips. Complete with O-rings, the tips attach more securely to the shaft. Hence, they don’t get stuck on the target.

Also, you get adjustable nocks. These are small, press-fit nocks that come in durable, impact-resistant plastic.

Ready-to-shoot package

This 30-inch arrow combines all components. It includes field point tips, rubber fletching glue, and nocks. Also, the package includes 12 arrows.

6. Excalibur Diablo 18-Inch Carbon Arrows

Compound crossbows dominate the market, no doubt. Though a bit traditional, recurve crossbows are also still competitive. And in this segment, few can match the quality of Excalibur recurve crossbows.

Excalibur, alongside Easton, has developed some of the best arrows for its Matrix Series crossbows. Termed Diablo, these 18-inch arrows reward you with blistering speed and unmatched accuracy.

Stiffer spine for high-poundage Excalibur Matrix crossbows

At 13.8 GPI, Diablo Carbon Arrow is a heavyweight contender. But at 18 inches, it’s shorter than most arrows with the same grain weight. Hence, it’s stiffer than its longer counterparts.

Such stiffness makes it compatible with high-poundage Excalibur Matrix crossbows. You can pair with Matrix GRZ2, Matrix Bulldog 330, or Matrix G340 crossbows. For the record, these crossbows have draw weights ranging from 200-230 pounds.

Blistering speed

Diablo carbon arrow is a speed demon. Shot from Matrix Series crossbows, it can do 305-340 feet per second. For that, it can take down the zippiest whitetail at a moment’s notice.

Heavier front insert for unparalleled accuracy

Diablo carbon arrow has a heavier front insert. It can fit both fixed and mechanical broadheads, 100 grains and up. Also, it rewards you with exceptional accuracy.

No need for nocks

This carbon arrow adopts a flatback insert. So, unlike other arrows, it doesn’t require nocks. Still, it offers more reliable contact with the string.

7. ANTSIR 20-Inch Hunting Archery Carbon Arrow

Among short-shaft arrows, the ANTSIR carbon arrow is the cheapest offering. But quality-wise, I wouldn’t rate it as cheap.

It’s a durable carbon arrow boasting consistent wall thickness. Also, it rewards you with maximum accuracy and excellent penetration.

Durable composite carbon shaft

Despite the price, this arrow doesn’t sacrifice quality. It has a composite carbon shaft of consistent wall thickness.

Excellent accuracy and penetration

At 20 inches, ANTSIR is a short-shaft arrow. Unlike longer versions, it’s more accurate. Also, it’s built for longer flights.

The shaft is rated at 13.75 grains per inch and comes fitted with 125-grain tips. Hence, it’s of sufficient weight for penetration edge.

Perfect for light-draw crossbows

This arrow is suitable for 40-60 pounds of crossbows. So, it has sufficient momentum, but not enough to make it a formidable hunter.

I’d consider it for target practice. But fitted with a broadhead, and considering the impressive speed, I’d say it can do damage to whitetails.

Standard accessories for easy repair and replacement

The accessories are pretty standard, but more than you can ask for the price. Aluminum inserts, standard field points, and moon nocks are easy to source.

8. PG1 Archery 30-Inch Carbon Arrow

It isn’t the best in its category. Nonetheless, it’s reasonably priced and has good speed and durability for target practice.

Also, I’d say it’s a value package. After all, you get a dozen ready-to-shoot carbon arrows.

Ready-to-shoot

PG1 arrows come ready to shoot out of the box. They’re matched with 100-grain field points, 3-inch vanes, and glued nocks.

Decent light-draw arrows for target practice

The 500-spine shaft isn’t as stiff. So, this carbon arrow is pretty much for light draws, say 30-60 pounds. And with composite carbon, it makes an excellent choice for long-lasting target practice.

But should you choose, you can switch the field points for broadheads. That way, it can do more damage. For instance, it can take down small deer, including whitetails.

Wide-range bow compatibility

You don’t have to worry about the type of bow you have in your arsenal. PGI carbon arrow fits all bow styles. Be it a recurve bow, compound bow, or longbow; it won’t disappoint.

Replaceable field points

You can switch the field point tips for a broadhead. But while replaceable, they don’t include O-rings. Nevertheless, the hold is still strong, making it less of an issue.

Unlike the field point tips, the nocks can’t be replaced. Instead, they’re glued onto the shaft.

9. Gold Tip Hunter XT Arrow

Gold Tip arrows are renowned for their reliability, effectiveness, and durability. From beginners to die-hard archers, these arrows are sure to please.

Among the long line of Gold Tip arrows, Hunter XT leads the pack. It’s among the most popular and successful and boasts a few new touches.

Lifetime durability

Well, the XT Series cost a bit more, and for valid reasons. Among other things, they’re exceptionally durable. The shaft, for instance, comes in shatter-resistant smart carbon construction. Likewise, the vanes are tougher than those in other models. Were I to pick an arrow that would last an entire lifetime, then Hunter XT would be the top choice.

Pretty darn straight

Except for Carbon Express, Hunter XT arrows have the most impressive straightness tolerance. At 0.003 inches, they provide much-needed accuracy.

A perfect balance of speed and penetration

Hunter XT is pretty much a mid-weight arrow. Hence, it offers the best of both worlds: speed and penetration power. For this reason, it suits any hunter, no matter their preferences. And that makes it the most versatile arrow ever made.

A multitude of options

Hunter XT series has many options for the spine, fletching, diameter, weight, and package quantity.

It’s available in five spine sizes of 250-500. As for fletching, you can choose between 2-inch raptor vanes or 4-inch feathers. Likewise, you can buy it as a shaft only and dress with the type of fletching you like.

The shaft diameter ranges from 0.291-0.309 inches. Overall, it’s available in five different diameter sizes.

The weight, on the other hand, varies from 9.3-10.6 grains per inch. Again, it’s available in five different weights. As for the package quantity, you can buy it in a pack of six or twelve.

10. GPP Archery Carbon 30-Inch Arrows

As far as target practice goes, GPP carbon arrows offer the best value. Well, they might be cheap, price-wise, but the quality is pretty decent.

These arrows shoot straight and true, at least for short distances. Also, they’re surprisingly durable.

Rugged durability

For the price, GPP arrows are surprisingly durable. They combine black carbon shafts and super-hard 100-grain steel field points. Hence, they can take a beating.

The perfect draw for target practice

As far as accuracy goes, these arrows will pretty much suffice. They can be accurate to within 3 inches at 40-50 yards. Or dead-accurate at within 20 yards. Hence, they shoot well for target practice.

Compatible with light-draw bows

GPP arrows are pretty much for light-draw compounds and recurve bows. At 40-60 pounds, they can penetrate stumps with ease. However, they don’t pack as much power for large prey.

Ready-to-shoot package

These arrows are fully dressed up and ready to shoot. They come fitted with field points, adjustable nocks, and colored fletching. Also, the package includes 12 arrows.

Best Arrows for Deer Hunting: Complete Guide

Construction Material

The construction material, specifically for the shaft, is paramount. There are four different types of shaft material: wood, aluminum, fiberglass, and carbon. Also, there are hybrids, which combine aluminum and carbon.

Wood, a more traditional material, is ideal for beginner practice. It’s not as long-lasting and tends to be a bit slower and heavier.

Fiberglass is a durable, cost-effective choice. It’s not susceptible to bending, hence remains straight. Such specs make it ideal for hunting.

Aluminum shafts are a popular choice in the bowhunting segment. They’re light, strong, and inexpensive. However, aluminum shafts are a bit heavier than their carbon counterparts.

Carbon is easily the most popular choice. It’s slightly and rewards users with more speed, accuracy, and penetration.

Hybrid shafts, a blend of carbon and aluminum, are fast and light. Also, they offer outstanding energy transfer. However, you pay more for an excellent performance.

Spine

The spine of an arrow is a measure of how much the shaft bends. The lower the spine, the stiffer the arrow. For instance, a 500-spine shaft bends or flexes more than a 250-spine shaft. Hence, the 250-spine shaft rewards you with more accuracy. Also, it can accommodate high-poundage bows.

Arrow Length

The shorter the arrow, the stiffer the shaft. Also, a short arrow is more accurate. And because it’s lighter, it rewards you with more speed.

A longer arrow tends to be heavier. Though not as fast, it retains its velocity better. Also, a longer arrow has a more penetration edge.

Shaft Weight

The shaft weight is expressed in Grains Per Inch (GPI). To get the overall shaft weight, you multiply the GPI rating with the shaft length. For instance, a 30-inch shaft with a GPI rating of 9.5 weighs 285 grains.

The lower the GPI rating, the lighter and faster the arrow. A heavier arrow with a higher GPI rating, on the other hand, isn’t as fast. However, it rewards you with bone-crushing penetration.

Mostly, the fastest arrows in the business have a GPI rating of 7.5 or lower. Anything from 8-10 GPI offers is considered mid-weight. These offer a perfect balance of speed and penetration. And for deeper, bone-crushing penetration, a GPI rating of at least 10 will do.

But other factors need consideration, such as arrow stiffness and the draw weight. For instance, a shaft with 13 GPI but with a weaker spine is only good for low-poundage bows. Hence, it won’t provide bone-crushing penetration.

Shaft Diameter

Most often, a thicker arrow lasts longer. However, the trajectory is more affected by the wind. That makes it ideal for target practice.

A thinner shaft, on the other hand, is less affected by the wind. Hence, it’s a more accurate and ideal choice for hunting.

Straightness Tolerance

Straightness is king, particularly in the world of carbon arrows. Most arrows have a straightness range of 0.001-0.006 inches.

A straightness rating of 0.001 offers more consistency than that of 0.006. hence, a lower rating is mostly preferred for elite hunters. Models, such as Carbon Express Maxima RED, take things the extra mile. It has a straightness tolerance of 0.0001, the best in the industry.

Bow Compatibility

An arrow is no good without a bow. But for the best performance, you need the right bow for your arrow. For that, I’d recommend that you refer to the arrow sizing chart.

Generally, high-poundage bows accommodate shorter, stiffer arrows. Longer arrows with a weaker spine, on the other hand, are ideal for light-draw bows.

Also, consider the type of bow that’s best for you. Cross-check to determine if your set of arrows is compatible with compound bows, crossbows, or recurve bows. Most offer wide-range compatibility across two or more types of bows.

Arrow Points

Ready-to-shoot arrows come complete with arrow points. Mostly, they include field points, which are ideal for small-game hunts and target practice. However, stiffer shafts with replaceable field points can accommodate broadheads to take down large prey.

Brand

Some brands go to the next level to provide a higher level of quality and performance. So, I think they deserve mention. Some top names to consider are Easton, Carbon Express, and Gold Tip.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Question: What’s the most accurate arrow for deer hunting?

Answer: Carbon Express Maxima RED is easily the most accurate. It offers laser-checked straightness and boasts dynamic spine control that makes broadheads fly better.

Question: What’s the best carbon arrow for bone-crushing penetration?

Answer: I’d go with Carbon Express PileDriver. It packs exceptional knock-down power to punch through big-boned animals.

Question: I need the most versatile arrow for deer hunting. Which one should I choose?

Answer: I’d recommend Gold Tip Hunter XT. It strikes a perfect balance of speed and penetration power, making it ideal for any hunter. Also, it has more size and spine options.

Conclusion

A quality set of arrows is essential for deer bowhunting. Among other things, it rewards you with accuracy, durability, and value for money. So far, I’ve outlined the best arrows for deer hunting to help you strike such a balance. If okay with you, let me know which arrow you find the most ideal.